et server suggestion Silent Servers Map Voting

[schNee]

...hello =)

 

so the last weeks some big maps were tested and a lot of people complaining on server about same maps. 

So i thought about a vote to ask all of you to make it easier for admins to decide. 

 

its's about maps which could be removed, I've looked up server status. some are just overplayed (italy, delivery) and some are just not nice to play e.g. with 2 flamer (Paris Bastille), some are just never played or not working due to bot failure (fata).

i put goldrush to remove because we have it twice and goldrush official is more playable.

 

the new maps are big maps with lot of space for a full server, they are all objective, so should be working for bots as well. 

the suggested maps i'd like to propose for some FA server.

 

i've added the dl links for the new maps, so you can have a look at them and maybe test

 

Stargate:

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/113-stargate-center-1945-final-sg-1945-finalpk3/

Bridges:

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/105-bridges-bridges-pk3/

MLB Bergheim:

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/1551-mlb-bergheim-beta-9/

HKF1:

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/407-hkf1-beta-13-hkf1v1-3pk3/

Canyon Depths:

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/1538-canyon-depths-beta-7/

Resurrection:

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/161-resurrection-resurrectionpk3/%C2%A0

Glider Assault:

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/49-glider-302-glider-302pk3/

 

Thanks for your time and i hope of a lot of votings

 

if you think others should be removed or added which i've overseen, pm me

 

UPDATEv1

 

cortex has been added to list =)

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/425-cortex-revised-cortexrevisedpk3/

 

UPDATEv2

 

MLB Daybreak added.

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/54-mlb-daybreak-mlb-daybreakpk3/

 

UPDATEv3

 

Breakout

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/185-breakout-breakout-371pk3/

 

Subway

http://fearless-assassins.com/files/file/103-subway-subwaypk3/

[Raw64life]

Just bumping this thread because not much has changed on Silent 1, and the complaints are getting louder and more frequent.

 

- Goldrush TE is still a dreadful map for 16v16 and needs to be replaced with the original version or just any other version

 

- People are complaining more and more about the same few maps getting played constantly. Personally I think increasing the 5 map rule to something like 7-8 would be a good remedy for this.

 

- People are just requesting new maps in general. Of course they rarely if ever sign up to the forum and post about it when you tell them to, but the demand is there nevertheless. Maps like Ice and Teuthonia that get played basically never sit there and rot when they could be replaced with maps people want to try.

 

I'll cross post this in the other relevant thread.

[Dovaah]

Also, we should delete baserace or at least have a more stable version :

 

When the server is full we got error message like this ( http://bildr.no/image/MEhkYTlW.jpeg ).

 

Which is really annoying especially when you can't aim (like myself) and the only shoot that should hit are "disabled" -> Hello darkness my old friend, i've come to talk with you again

 

PS: glad you made that topic schnee

[Raw64life]

Also, we should delete baserace or at least have a more stable version :

 

When the server is full we got error message like this ( http://bildr.no/image/MEhkYTlW.jpeg ).

 

Which is really annoying especially when you can't aim (like myself) and the only shoot that should hit are "disabled" -> Hello darkness my old friend, i've come to talk with you again

 

PS: glad you made that topic schnee

 

I didn't want to say it outright because I hate the map but +1 deleting Baserace.

[Thule]

Just bumping this thread because not much has changed on Silent 1, and the complaints are getting louder and more frequent.

 

- Goldrush TE is still a dreadful map for 16v16 and needs to be replaced with the original version or just any other version

 

- People are complaining more and more about the same few maps getting played constantly. Personally I think increasing the 5 map rule to something like 7-8 would be a good remedy for this.

 

- People are just requesting new maps in general. Of course they rarely if ever sign up to the forum and post about it when you tell them to, but the demand is there nevertheless. Maps like Ice and Teuthonia that get played basically never sit there and rot when they could be replaced with maps people want to try.

 

I'll cross post this in the other relevant thread.

 

^ Agreed with all this.  New maps in general would be a good idea on Silent.  I too have been seeing a pretty steady cadence of complaints recently.

 

Subway would be great.  Bridges and Ressurrection sound good too.  A few other names I thought I'd toss out are:  Axis Lab, Stalingrad, Eagles_2ways_b3, and Lighthouse.

 

 

I didn't want to say it outright because I hate the map but +1 deleting Baserace.

 

+1.  To deleting that one.

[schNee]

i thought about making different map rotations.

so standard maps + some customs 

[MosesIsComingLookBusy]

before removing any maps, should look into the changing the version of Goldrush and Oasis, reason; those are popular maps which should NOT be removed, but it's the wrong version for the server. In the past we tried to fix the issue by changing the spawntimes for Axis and Allies. Did not change much. 

 

Deli, Radar, Italy, Beach, Battery, Beerun, Goldrush can't be removed since they are quite popular maps. 

 

Having 3 of em on each rotations, where the rotations are changed every 2nd week would be good though.

 

 

I gave my vote even though I have not seen/heard half of these maps before. (Where they voted to be added to the list?)

[Thule]

Deli, Radar, Italy, Beach, Battery, Beerun, Goldrush can't be removed since they are quite popular maps.

 

True that, Italy, Beerrun and Seawall Battery are perennial favorites.

[schNee]

before removing any maps, should look into the changing the version of Goldrush and Oasis, reason; those are popular maps which should NOT be removed, but it's the wrong version for the server. In the past we tried to fix the issue by changing the spawntimes for Axis and Allies. Did not change much. 

 

Deli, Radar, Italy, Beach, Battery, Beerun, Goldrush can't be removed since they are quite popular maps. 

 

Having 3 of em on each rotations, where the rotations are changed every 2nd week would be good though.

 

 

I gave my vote even though I have not seen/heard half of these maps before. (Where they voted to be added to the list?)

 

 

 

no i spend a nerd weekend and looked up big maps and tested them to see if they maybe good. some were voted by people to be added. 

i know about the goldrush issue and will look it up. 

agree with the popular maps being in the rotations. 

 

=)

[MosesIsComingLookBusy]

no i spend a nerd weekend and looked up big maps and tested them to see if they maybe good. some were voted by people to be added. 

i know about the goldrush issue and will look it up. 

agree with the popular maps being in the rotations. 

 

=)

 

 

Nice, thank you! 

 

To fix the goldrush map, chnage the current version Goldrush SW to either Goldrush GA or Goldrush original (stock map).

Same for Oasis, just the other way around, current version Oasis original (stock map) chnage to Oasis SW.

[zrong]

Voted for 5 out and 5 in, this is how I would rate them even though they are really huge maps for hardcore server.

 

 

1. Canyon Depths

 

2. Bridges Final 

 

3. MLB Daybreak / Ressurrection *

 

4. Breakout

 

(?) HKF1 Beta 1.3

[pottokeR.]

+1 On any other version of Gold Rush!

[iCiCeLzz]

Can trainyard please be added to HC??? Its a vintage rtcw map 

[schNee]

ok the rotation suggestions was send out by today. 

plus maps to add and remove. 

 

so fingers crossed we get new maps soon =)

[!MX]

Gold rush map it will be good if comes to originates... 

 

More easy to allies rush and probably, more fight.