Platinum VIP Dest!Ny Posted March 30, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 30, 2017 Big Dad Ritch Bon Scott Brian Johnson Bruce Dickinson Chris Cornell Dave Mustaine David Coverdale David Draiman Doro Pesch Eddie Vedder Geoff Tate Grace Slick Ian Gillan James Hetfield Jim Morrison Jimi Jamison John Mellencamp Paul Rodgers Phil Anselmo Rob Halford Robert Plant Rod Stewart Roger Daltry Roger Hodgson Ronnie James Dio Serj Tankian Steve Perry Sting Matt Bellamy - shouldn't have lasted this long, tbh Was hoping my boy could remain in the shadows a little longer 1 Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted March 30, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 30, 2017 Big Dad Ritch Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve PerrySting Grace Slick - how the hell did she even last this long? 1 Quote
Helsen Posted March 31, 2017 Posted March 31, 2017 . Big Dad Ritch Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve PerrySting goodbye mr Draiman. ]It was a nice run, but the joke lasted long enough now 1 Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted March 31, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 31, 2017 Big Dad Ritch Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve PerrySting John Mellencamp - If I can sing liker him, then he's no legend Quote
Helsen Posted March 31, 2017 Posted March 31, 2017 . Big Dad Ritch Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve PerrySting Rod Steward : maybe we better also make a best pop singer section? Not that he will get very far there either Quote
P8rpl3h4z3 Posted March 31, 2017 Posted March 31, 2017 Sting, not a rock singer, pop reggea or soul would be closer genre Big Dad Ritch Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve Perry 1 Quote
Dingus Posted April 2, 2017 Author Posted April 2, 2017 Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve Perry Buh-Bye Big Dad Ritch 1 Quote
Helsen Posted April 2, 2017 Posted April 2, 2017 . Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve Perry Bye bye Paul Rodgers, great singer... but at least some here are just better Quote
P8rpl3h4z3 Posted April 2, 2017 Posted April 2, 2017 farewell Steve Perry, heres alot better ones left Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James Dio 1 Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted April 2, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted April 2, 2017 Choices are getting harder to make. Bon Scott - Love what you did when you were still alive, but not in the same class as the others here Brian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James Dio Quote
Dingus Posted April 3, 2017 Author Posted April 3, 2017 Brian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James Dio Jimi Jamison - Career wrapped around 1 song. More Pop than Rock to begin with. 2 Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted April 3, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted April 3, 2017 (edited) Brian Johnson Bruce Dickinson Chris Cornell Dave Mustaine Doro Pesch Eddie Vedder Geoff Tate Ian Gillan James Hetfield Jim Morrison Phil Anselmo Rob Halford Robert Plant Roger Daltry Roger Hodgson Ronnie James Dio Jimi Jamison - Career wrapped around 1 song. More Pop than Rock to begin with. How did I miss that one??? Good call, Dingus Edited April 3, 2017 by -=HipKat=- 1 Quote
Helsen Posted April 3, 2017 Posted April 3, 2017 (edited) . Brian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James Dio cut out Eddie Vedder. So I left the best of the ' grunge-bunch' still here. A lot to cut away still and it seems to get easier along the way. This whole thing is ofcourse way to biased and way to broad to begin with. It is all a matter of taste and knowledge... When you are young atm.. most hear rock-songs from games like GTA it seems. I get kids who are totally wild about Nirvana, but don't know who Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, Mudhoney, Screaming Trees, Alice in Chains, Stone Temple Pilots wre for example. That will be the same for the bit older ones... like thinking Sammy Hagar was all about Van Halen :/ e.g. This is a bout rock singers, but half of it is pop. Also the other way around: why include Doro and not put in Till Lindeman? Or if pop and rock are mixed: where were Jon Bon Jovi or Fish? And where is Ozzy Osborne in all of this? As said... taste and knowledge (but also where u live e.g.). It would have been better to divide the stuff first.. like: rock of 70ties, 80 ties , 90 ties. I did not put him in.. but Steve Perry comparing to Rob Halford or Phil Anselmo is not possible. Are we taking in consideration only singing quality, or also influence on the genre, songwriting qualities, impact etc. Because maybe even Arnel Pineda is a way better singer then Steve ever was in Journey (ow.. I love Journey tbh). I for certain think Bon Scott is way more important in ACDC than Brian ever was. Also in defining rock music. Brian tried his whole carreer trying to sound like Bon.. lol So conclusion: it is fun, but complicated. That is also a reason to hesitate joining a nice race for 50 greatest guitar players... who is to judge in that? Then a guitar player with a lot of make up on his face, who knows 2 tricks on the damned thing gets maybe more votes then a person like Joe Satriani ... because where is Satriani nowadays? Or Vai, or even Eddie. . And in taste... is Dimebag comparable objectively with Santana or the way too much apreciated Clapton? I bet there will be no Berry to be found (too old) or Vaughan (too dead) . But maybe fun anyways Edited April 3, 2017 by Helsen 2 Quote
Helsen Posted April 3, 2017 Posted April 3, 2017 . Brian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDoro PeschGeoff TateIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRoger HodgsonRonnie James Dio Sorry guys: Roger Daltrey has left the building. He went to the pop-section Quote
Helsen Posted April 3, 2017 Posted April 3, 2017 (edited) Hipkat said: Axl Rose. I just hate him. His voice breaks mirrors and ruins small children's lives I think the latter is actually a good thing Edited April 3, 2017 by Helsen 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.