Dingus Posted March 26, 2017 Author Posted March 26, 2017 Angela GassowBig Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid BowieDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderElton JohnFreddy MercuryGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampMatt BellamyPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSammy HagarScott WeilandSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Bruce Springsteen...why? That's why. 1 Quote
Helsen Posted March 26, 2017 Posted March 26, 2017 . Angela GassowBig Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid BowieDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderElton JohnGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampMatt BellamyPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSammy HagarScott WeilandSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Well, it seems it is very easy to strip most of them, but since a parody is supposedly a good reason to kick someone... here we go buhbye fred 1 Quote
Dingus Posted March 26, 2017 Author Posted March 26, 2017 If you're going to seriously compare the vocals of Bruce Springsteen to Freddie Mercury...there is no hope for your ears. Bruce Springsteen cannot sing a tune...he growls and screams. Seriously. You still want to keep your pick with Freddie Mercury? 1 Quote
Helsen Posted March 27, 2017 Posted March 27, 2017 (edited) If you're going to seriously compare the vocals of Bruce Springsteen to Freddie Mercury...there is no hope for your ears. Bruce Springsteen cannot sing a tune...he growls and screams. Seriously. You still want to keep your pick with Freddie Mercury? First of all: thank you for your sound critisism of my taste and choices. Second: I found no reason in your dismissal besides a video in where one counts, and shows some gimmicks one uses in their performances. I thought... if that is the criterium to choose to kick singers: who is the master of gimmicks? So that made the choice easy. But ok... now on the content. In my opinion growling and screaming are a good part of the singing arsenal of a ROCK singer. And examples of Springsteen singing (in tune) are abundant. So that makes him complete. Also a carreer that is now already lasting 45 years, in which he wrote and sang a immense array of particularly great rock-songs makes him very qualified. What is even more remarkable: he still sings, rocks and growls live on stage on a very regular basis, in a 3 hours or more show in which he stays on tune, captures the audience and can still give meaning and content to songs that are sometimes even from the 70ties, but also from the 2000s. There is no one that has even come close to give and maintain those kind of performances. Not on the account on singing... but I find the songs of Springsteen having also a lot more content than the songs of Freddie. Ok last: I do find Freddie Mercury one of the greatest singers that ever lived. But I do not qualify him as a rock singer pur sang. For me he represents popmusic, not rock. Although he had some of the greatest rocksongs I am also taking in account songs like Barcelona, The great pretender, i'm going slightly mad e.g. , . In my opinion (and I state again.. in MY opinion ) he became too much pop. And if popmusic would have been the criterium he would have been my number 1 choice, no doubt. Ofcourse there are more singers in this list which I think do not belong here, but in pop (Sting, Steward, Elton John e.g.) but I just started with the biggest fish. So I think: you kicked out the person that maybe qualifies best here as a rock singer, I kicked out the best pop singer. Maybe rethink your criteria too? Edited March 27, 2017 by Helsen 1 Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted March 27, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 27, 2017 Angela GassowBig Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid BowieDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderElton JohnGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampMatt BellamyPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSammy HagarSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Scott Weiland - It's getting tougher to make picks but I'm going with Scott. Great band and great songs but not really a great voice. Layne Staley may have been a better choice to represent Grunge that Scott Weiland 1 Quote
Dingus Posted March 28, 2017 Author Posted March 28, 2017 Angela GassowBig Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid BowieDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderElton JohnGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampMatt BellamyPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Sammy Hagar Even Eddie Van Halen knew that it was Dave or the grave! RIP Sammy 1 Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted March 28, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 28, 2017 Big Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid BowieDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderElton JohnGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampMatt BellamyPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Angela Gassow is one of the best female Death Metal singers ever, but no legend. Besides, I'm pretty sure she sings through processors and mad effects 1 Quote
Ch315eY Posted March 29, 2017 Posted March 29, 2017 Big Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderElton JohnGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampMatt BellamyPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Every time I hear his voice on the radio my ears bleed and a part of me dies a little inside. Never could understand why so many people like him but the only list David Bowie belongs on is the worlds worst singers list. Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted March 29, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 29, 2017 Big Dad Ritch Bon Scott Brian Johnson Bruce Dickinson Chris Cornell Dave Mustaine David Coverdale David Draiman Doro Pesch Eddie Vedder Elton John Geoff Tate Grace Slick Ian Gillan James Hetfield Jim Morrison Jimi Jamison John Mellencamp Matt Bellamy Paul Rodgers Phil Anselmo Rob Halford Robert Plant Rod Stewart Roger Daltry Roger Hodgson Ronnie James Dio Serj Tankian Steve Perry Sting Every time I hear his voice on the radio my ears bleed and a part of me dies a little inside. Never could understand why so many people like him but the only list David Bowie belongs on is the worlds worst singers list. Oh no you didn't!!!! 1 Quote
Helsen Posted March 29, 2017 Posted March 29, 2017 . Big Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampMatt BellamyPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Ok, just to not cause a lot of controversy again: Elton John has been thanked and sent to the list of pop/singers. He was never a rock singer. 1 Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted March 29, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 29, 2017 Big Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSerj TankianSteve PerrySting Matt Bellamy - shouldn't have lasted this long, tbh Quote
zrong Posted March 30, 2017 Posted March 30, 2017 Took off Captain Beefheart. For one thing, who the hell ever heard of him and 2nd, he and his band just suck Sorry, but I stopped reading topic here... Quote
Platinum VIP -=HipKat=- Posted March 30, 2017 Platinum VIP Posted March 30, 2017 Sorry, but I stopped reading topic here... Why am I not surprised? Quote
Helsen Posted March 30, 2017 Posted March 30, 2017 . Big Dad RitchBon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid CoverdaleDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve PerrySting Well this list has for certain a lot more to throw away than to keep. But to make choices easier for folks: bye bye Serj Tankian. That dude can not, really can not, sing in tune live. Saw him, total disaster, total distaster. True. 1 Quote
P8rpl3h4z3 Posted March 30, 2017 Posted March 30, 2017 David Coverdale, neva heard of him, i just listened some of his songs and didnt like bb Big Dad Ritch Bon ScottBrian JohnsonBruce DickinsonChris CornellDave MustaineDavid DraimanDoro PeschEddie VedderGeoff TateGrace SlickIan GillanJames HetfieldJim MorrisonJimi JamisonJohn MellencampPaul RodgersPhil AnselmoRob HalfordRobert PlantRod StewartRoger DaltryRoger HodgsonRonnie James DioSteve PerrySting Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.